Screenshot 2025-09-17 at 20.06.31.png
Logo of Coplentz Agency with a curved white line above the name in a black background.

Welcome to Coblentz Agency
Comprehensive Protection, Hometown Service – Always Focused on You.

Logo with black oval background, blue and white text reading "Protecting What Matters Since 1933".

The Coblentz Agency Advantage

Since 1933, our experienced insurance agents have helped generations of local residents and business owners protect what matters most. As your neighbors, we’re dedicated to building long-term relationships through honest advice, customized insurance plans, and exceptional customer care. At Coblentz Agency, you’re not just a policyholder – you’re part of our community.

Personal Insurance Coverage for Ohio & Indiana Residents

A happy couple standing in front of a house, holding a clipboard, smiling at the camera.
A man with glasses and a beard, smiling and giving a thumbs-up, sitting in the driver's seat of a car.
A person wearing a black helmet and leather jacket riding a motorcycle on a two-lane road surrounded by green and yellow trees during sunset.
A recreational vehicle parked in a forested campground with tall pine trees, a mountain in the background, and a picnic table.
Four happy older adults, two women and two men, standing outdoors against a clear blue sky, smiling and embracing each other.
A sleek motorboat floating on calm water near a rocky shoreline with trees and mountains in the background under a blue sky with scattered clouds.

Commercial Insurance Solutions in Ohio & Indiana

Smiling woman in a gray apron standing behind a counter at a bakery or cafe, with baked goods and glassware in the background.
Street view of a modern four-story brick building with large windows, leafless trees along the sidewalk, parked cars, and a blue sky with scattered clouds.
A row of white delivery vans and trucks parked outside a commercial building.
An aerial view of a combine harvester working in a large golden wheat field, with dust clouds billowing behind it.
A young man with a beard wearing a blue shirt and black apron looking at a digital device, standing behind a coffee bar with an espresso machine and stacked cups in the background.
A rural farm scene with green grass, red barns, a silo, and trees, under a clear blue sky.
Two women wearing beige aprons standing in front of a cafe with blue door and windows, smiling.

Protecting New Madison Families and Businesses Since 1933

Local individuals and businesses trust Coblentz Agency for dependable insurance coverage and hometown service. We live and work right here in New Madison, so we’re committed to helping you safeguard your home, vehicle, business, and loved ones with affordable, tailored insurance solutions.

Group of six diverse smiling people standing in a bright office with large windows
A man and woman celebrating with fists in the air and shouting excitedly against a plain light gray background.
Two women and one man sitting at a table in a meeting, with a woman on the right holding a smartphone and a laptop open in front of her, during a consultation or interview.

Need to review your policy, pay a bill, or get support after hours? Use the links below for quick self-service options through our partner companies, or call us at (937) 996-1581 for policy changes and personal assistance.

Client Center – Easy Access to Your Insurance Needs

Icon of a magnifying glass with a checkmark examining a stack of papers or documents.
Icon of a checkbook with a lock symbol, representing secure banking or financial security.
Icon of a document with a ribbon or seal at the bottom, representing a certificate or award.
Icon of a headset with the text '24/7' indicating 24 hours a day, 7 days a week customer support.
Icon of an identification card with a person's image and text lines.

Trusted Insurance Carriers

We partner with top-rated insurance providers to offer you the best coverage options and peace of mind.

  • Medical Mutual logo featuring a teal abstract globe and the company name in gray text.

    New List Item

  • Close-up of a colorful banner with yellow, gray, and blue sections.

    New List Item

  • Logo of Celina Insurance Group with the company name in navy blue, a green leaf above the 'i' in 'celina'.

    New List Item

  • Anthem insurance logo with text and symbols

    New List Item

  • Logo of Acuity Insurance featuring a stylized red and pink heart and bold black and gray text.

    New List Item

  • The logo of the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA), featuring stacked blue rectangles and the acronym AICPA in black text.

    New List Item

  • Wayne Insurance Group logo with the name in large blue letters and 'Insurance Group' in smaller black letters below.

    New List Item

  • Progressive logo in blue and black text

    New List Item

  • Logo of Cincinnati Insurance Companies featuring a stylized suspension bridge above the company name.

    New List Item

  • Goodville Mutual Insurance Group logo with green and blue geometric design

    New List Item

  • Humana logo in green text.

    New List Item

  • Safeco Insurance logo with purple and black text on a white background.

    New List Item

  • Aetna logo featuring a purple heart symbol and the company name in purple text.

    New List Item

  • Sign for Rain and Hail, a Chubb insurance company, with a blue background and white text featuring a globe graphic.

    New List Item

Connect with a neighbor who cares. Contact us today and experience the Coblentz Agency difference – where local service meets decades of expertise.