The Coblentz Difference: Friendly, Local, and Always on Your Side

Choosing insurance is a big deal—but you don’t have to do it alone. At Coblentz Agency, we live and work right here in the New Madison area, and we treat you like neighbors because you are our neighbors. As an independent insurance agency, we’re not tied to just one company. That means we can shop around and find the coverage that actually fits your life—not just the policy a single carrier wants to sell you.

Here’s what makes working with us different:

• More Options, Less Hassle
  We work with several trusted insurance providers. Whether you’re looking for auto, home, life, or business insurance, we’ll help you compare plans and pick the one that checks all the right boxes—without overspending.

• Straight Talk, Not Sales Talk
  We don’t expect you to speak “insurance.” We break things down clearly so you know exactly what you're getting. And if something ever goes wrong, we’ll be here to walk you through the claims process step-by-step.

• Local Know-How
  From understanding the risks of Ohio weather to helping you meet local insurance requirements, our team has the local insight that national call centers just don’t.

• Ongoing Support for Life’s Changes
  Need to add a new driver? Renovating your home? Starting a side business? We’re here for all of it. Our team is just a phone call or quick visit away.

Let’s Get You Covered

Call us today or stop by our local office to talk through your options. No pressure, just honest advice. Whether you live in New Madison, Brookville, Dayton, Centerville, or anywhere in between, we’re proud to help protect what matters most to you.

Let’s make insurance simple—and maybe even a little friendly.